Dumb Lemming Moment: Stating Problems Without Solutions
Present Possible Solutions to Problems
A wise C-level once said to me, “Don’t present me with a problem, include potential solutions to the problem.” This was simple, yet elegant advice that I’ve received as a knowledge worker. Have you ever sent an email or told your boss only the problem without possible solutions? Have you told your boss a solution, acted on it, without sharing the problem or any derivative of this situation?
These situations are Dumb Lemming moments. For example, when an alarmed direct report freaks out, recommends a hasty solution to their boss without even saying what the problem was. I’ve seen emails where a direct reports says, “I bought this software program but it doesn’t work!” The boss reads the email and wonders, “Why did you buy it? What was the original problem you were trying to solve?” Most likely, the boss would have been able to recommend the right solutions if only the direct report would have shared the problem.
Choose C, Don’t Do A or B
Common sense? Yes, it is; however, you’d be surprised how many people do only A, B, or A and B, but not C:
A. Present only problems with no solutions.
B. Present solutions, completely skipping the problem they were trying to solve.
C. Present problem with possible solutions.
Problems with Solutions Approach
So they next time you have a problem, do the following:
- Identify the problem statement, thinking it through to understand underlying causes and effects, etc.
- Identify proposed solutions.
- Choose a solution that you’d recommend, noting pros/cons to each solution.
- Write it down/write the email (subject should be obvious like “Competitor Issue, Proposed Solutions”).
- Meet with your boss if you have to, but chances are your boss won’t have the time. Email it. If you’ve completed steps 1-4, then your boss will probably sign off on it unless your boss have ideas they want to kick around with you or if they have to approve something.
I appreciated problems with recommended solutions approach when I was at the C-level. It was a huge time savings. I trained my direct reports to use this approach. If my direct reports had a problem, they thought it through, and then identified possible solutions. They would pick one solution to recommend to me. I’d receive an email with a specific subject heading.
If they needed a decision, the subject header would read: “Lori tasks - Review/approve X,Y, and Z.” The email would be flagged with a due date so it would remind me to act if I didn’t. In the email body, the problem statement was brief and to the point. They would list bulleted possible solutions, recommending one. If they need to review it with me to make a decision, great. We would review it together, often coming up with a new solution or going with through the solutions and identifying the best one.
Smart Lemming Tip: Don’t just tell your boss what the problem is, think it through. What are the potential solutions? What makes sense? What would you recommend? These are starting points for discussion and decision making. Also, it shows you aren’t just reacting, saying the sky is falling. You’ve identified possible ways to keep the sky from falling.
Similar Posts:
- 23 Ways to be Happy at Work: #7 - What is the Problem? How to Identify Solutions.
- 12 Questions for Career Mindfulness: #2 If you wrote an email to yourself on attitude adjustment, how would it read?
- How to Avoid a Whack A Mole Management Style: Manage the Problem, Not the Symptoms
- 8 Ways to Become an Effective Executive
- Smart Lemming Diary: It’s all about Goals & Objectives



This goes directly to one of my biggest pet peeves with direct reports: Give me all the information I need. I understand our business and our systems, but I wasn’t with you when you discovered this bug or problem, so the details are missing for me.
I’ve run out of ways to explain it/request it from one of my junior staff. I’ve tried positive reinforcement. Such as when he does provide me information and alternatives and lists out the pros/cons and his recommendation, I try to take his recommendation (as long I see it as truly viable) even if I might have gone a different route. All that seems to come from that is the next time he simply gives me a solution since he expects I’ll simply take it. And we’re right back to beginning.
I recognize this post from a previous incarnation of Smart Lemming. One of my favorites, glad it’s been brought back to life.
~ Lisa
Back to herding cats …
You do have cats to herd. Gees, that would be my pet peeve too if my direct reports had done this. It would be that movie that bugs me, Ground Hogs Day. By the end of the movie, I want to scream.
Thanks for noticing the post. I’m slowly adding content from old Drupal site into this one, with minor updates and edits (I tend to leave out words, mostly verbs).